I have never argued against this because in the back of my mind im wondering if
Timken is making BOTH ball type and roller type bearings in these outer dimensions.
I just have not had time to research that yet. This is the reason I put considerable thought and effort into trying to remove the seals (without noticeable damage in order to receive refund) of the Timkens in question that I have....I want to know if they are balls or rollers. At $50 a pop I will figure it out another way. It's not on me anyways, I gave Rockauto the correct info and they COULD POSSIBLY be selling the wrong product from Timken. IF this is the case then I would suspect other retailers of having the wrong product from Timken also.
I would suspect that the balls are intended for lighter duty applications that don't have to deal with the same dynamic forces as a wheel. If all this were true it would explain almost everything.
Last edited by Motorhead; 08-20-2014 at 07:57 AM.
Your problem isn't the problem. Your reaction is the problem.
I have had bad luck(same grinding noise as Timkens) with the Moog/National/Precision/DT Components/Carquest/Federal Mogul bearings from O'riellys at $40 a pop. Yes all those companies use the exact same part number, and what does that tell you? ......there are about 5 or 6 companies in the world that actually make these bearings and the rest rebox. You wouldn't believe how many more brands are listed in cross reference charts as replacements(sample list included). What I don't know is which ones are rollers and which ones are not.
Upon removal of the one failed Moog/National bearing it came apart and revealed balls inside, all bets off. I didn't even try the other one, they both went back. I want rollers because they have at least ten times the surface area for wear and load forces.
So to answer your question would require knowing whether or not those hubs have the same bearings as the ones that failed me in the driveway (part number 513058).
SKF FW115
National 513058
Precision Seals & Bearings 513058
DT Components 513058
NIPPARTS J4710520
HERTH+BUSS JAKOPARTS J4710520
GREEN RW824
SEALED POWER F-S143
CARQUEST 513058
FEDERAL MOGUL 510058
Moog: 513058
NTN: ET-CR1-0846
SKF FW115 Wheel Bearing SKF FW115 Wheel Bearing Direct Details»
TIMKEN SET49 Wheel Bearing and Race Set TIMKEN SET49 Wheel Bearing and Race Set Direct Details»
DT Components 513058 Wheel Bearing DT Components 513058 Wheel Bearing Direct Details»
Precision Seals & Bearings 513058 Wheel Bearing Precision Seals & Bearings 513058 Wheel Bearing Direct Details»
GREEN RW824 Wheel Bearing GREEN RW824 Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
SEALED POWER F-S143 Wheel Bearing SEALED POWER F-S143 Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
FORD E6DZ-1215A Wheel Bearing FORD E6DZ-1215A Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
FORD E9DZ-1215A Wheel Bearing FORD E9DZ-1215A Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
L&S Bearing FV3028 Wheel Bearing L&S Bearing FV3028 Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
FAG 579102A Wheel Bearing FAG 579102A Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
FAG FW958 Wheel Bearing FAG FW958 Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
HYUNDAI 52710-26510 Wheel Bearing Kit HYUNDAI 52710-26510 Wheel Bearing Kit Indirect Details»
HYUNDAI 52710-26530 Wheel Bearing Kit HYUNDAI 52710-26530 Wheel Bearing Kit Indirect Details»
KIA 0K552-33-047 Wheel Bearing Kit KIA 0K552-33-047 Wheel Bearing Kit Indirect Details»
KIA 50310-3E101 Wheel Bearing Kit KIA 50310-3E101 Wheel Bearing Kit Indirect Details»
KIA 50310-3E200 Wheel Bearing Kit KIA 50310-3E200 Wheel Bearing Kit Indirect Details»
KIA 52710-26510 Wheel Bearing Kit KIA 52710-26510 Wheel Bearing Kit Indirect Details»
KIA 51720-2J000 Wheel Bearing KIA 51720-2J000 Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
KIA 51720-2J001 Wheel Bearing Kit KIA 51720-2J001 Wheel Bearing Kit Indirect Details»
KIA 51720-2J100 Wheel Bearing KIA 51720-2J100 Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
KIA 51720-FL-047 Wheel Bearing Kit KIA 51720-FL-047 Wheel Bearing Kit Indirect Details»
KIA 50310-3E102 Wheel Bearing Kit KIA 50310-3E102 Wheel Bearing Kit Indirect Details»
KIA 0K56B-33-047 Wheel Bearing KIA 0K56B-33-047 Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
HYUNDAI 51720-2J001 Wheel Bearing HYUNDAI 51720-2J001 Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
HYUNDAI 52710-26500 Wheel Bearing Kit HYUNDAI 52710-26500 Wheel Bearing Kit Indirect Details»
KOYO DU4276C Wheel Bearing KOYO DU4276C Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
TIMKEN 513058 Wheel Bearing TIMKEN 513058 Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
FORD F1DC-1215AA Wheel Bearing FORD F1DC-1215AA Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
FORD F1SZ-1215A Wheel Bearing FORD F1SZ-1215A Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
JAGUAR MJA1830AD Wheel Bearing Kit JAGUAR MJA1830AD Wheel Bearing Kit Indirect Details»
JAGUAR MJA1830AE Wheel Bearing Kit JAGUAR MJA1830AE Wheel Bearing Kit Indirect Details»
FORD E9DC-1215AA Wheel Bearing FORD E9DC-1215AA Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
FORD E6DC-1215AA Wheel Bearing FORD E6DC-1215AA Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
FEDERAL MOGUL 510058 Wheel Bearing FEDERAL MOGUL 510058 Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
FEDERAL MOGUL 513028 Wheel Bearing FEDERAL MOGUL 513028 Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
TIMKEN WB000016 Front Wheel Bearing TIMKEN WB000016 Front Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
OE 0K552-33-047 Wheel Bearing OE 0K552-33-047 Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
OE 0K56A-33-047 Wheel Bearing OE 0K56A-33-047 Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
OE 50310-3E200 Wheel Bearing OE 50310-3E200 Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
OE 52710-26500 Wheel Bearing OE 52710-26500 Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
OE 52710-26510 Wheel Bearing OE 52710-26510 Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
OE 52710-26530 Wheel Bearing OE 52710-26530 Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
OE E6DC-1215AA Wheel Bearing OE E6DC-1215AA Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
OE E6DZ-1215A Wheel Bearing OE E6DZ-1215A Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
OE E9DC-1215AA Wheel Bearing OE E9DC-1215AA Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
OE E9DZ-1215A Wheel Bearing OE E9DZ-1215A Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
OE F1DC-1215AA Wheel Bearing OE F1DC-1215AA Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
OE MJA1830AD Wheel Bearing OE MJA1830AD Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
SKF BAH-0209 Wheel Bearing SKF BAH-0209 Wheel Bearing Indirect Details»
CHRYSLER 5272447AA Wheel Bearing Kit CHRYSLER 5272447AA Wheel Bearing Kit Indirect Details»
Some repeats but there are plenty more......
SNR R186.08 ]Wheel Bearing Kit SNR R186.08 Array Direct Details»
ASHIKA 44-19013 Wheel Bearing Kit ASHIKA 44-19013 Array Direct Details»
JAPKO 419013 Wheel Bearing Kit JAPKO 419013 Array Direct Details»
TIMKEN 510058 Front Wheel Bearing TIMKEN 510058 Array Direct Details»
JAPANPARTS KK-19013 Wheel Bearing Kit JAPANPARTS KK-19013 Array Direct Details»
SKF FW115 Wheel Bearing SKF FW115 Array Direct Details»
TIMKEN SET49 Wheel Bearing and Race Set TIMKEN SET49 Array Direct Details»
DT Components 510058 Wheel Bearing Kit DT Components 510058 Array Direct Details»
BRT Bearings PWK0616 Wheel Bearing Kit BRT Bearings PWK0616 Array Direct Details»
Automotive Bearings ABK616 Wheel Bearing Kit Automotive Bearings ABK616 Array Direct Details»
Precision Seals & Bearings 510058 Wheel Brg Precision Seals & Bearings 510058 Array Direct Details»
PARTS MASTER PM510058 Front Wheel Bearing PARTS MASTER PM510058 Array Direct Details»
TRISCAN 8530 10150 Wheel Bearing Kit TRISCAN 8530 10150 Array Direct Details»
NATIONAL 510058 Front Wheel Bearing NATIONAL 510058 Array Direct Details»
CHRYSLER 5272448AA Wheel Bearing Kit CHRYSLER 5272448AA Array Indirect Details»
FEDERAL MOGUL 510058 Wheel Bearing FEDERAL MOGUL 510058 Array Indirect Details»
CHRYSLER 05272447-AA Wheel Bearing Kit CHRYSLER 05272447-AA Array Indirect Details»
CHRYSLER 0 5272 448AA Wheel Bearing Kit CHRYSLER 0 5272 448AA Array Indirect Details»
Precision Seals & Bearings 513058 Wheel Bearing Precision Seals & Bearings 513058 Array Indirect Details»
HYUNDAI 52710-26510 Wheel Bearing Kit HYUNDAI 52710-26510 Array Indirect Details»
HYUNDAI 52710-26530 Wheel Bearing Kit HYUNDAI 52710-26530 Array Indirect Details»
KIA 0K552-33-047 Wheel Bearing Kit KIA 0K552-33-047 Array Indirect Details»
KIA 50310-3E200 Wheel Bearing Kit KIA 50310-3E200 Array Indirect Details»
KIA 50310-3E101 Wheel Bearing Kit KIA 50310-3E101 Array Indirect Details»
SEALED POWER F-S143 Wheel Bearing SEALED POWER F-S143 Array Indirect Details»
FAG 579102A Wheel Bearing FAG 579102A Array Indirect Details»
FAG FW958 Wheel Bearing FAG FW958 Array Indirect Details»
SPIDAN 27657 Wheel Bearing Kit SPIDAN 27657 Array Indirect Details»
MOTAQUIP VBK1214 Wheel Bearing Kit MOTAQUIP VBK1214 Array Indirect Details»
BLUE PRINT ADA108213 Wheel Bearing Kit BLUE PRINT ADA108213 Array Indirect Details»
FIRST LINE FBK1000 Wheel Bearing Kit FIRST LINE FBK1000 Array Indirect Details»
SKF FWB115 Wheel Bearing SKF FWB115 Array Indirect Details»
BCA 513058 Wheel Bearing BCA 513058 Array Indirect Details»
NTN 4T-CRI-0821 Wheel Bearing NTN 4T-CRI-0821 Array Indirect Details»
NTN ET-CR1-0846 Wheel Bearing NTN ET-CR1-0846 Array Indirect Details»
NTN ETCR10846LLCS1 Wheel Bearing NTN ETCR10846LLCS1 Array Indirect Details»
NTN ETCR10846LLCS1#01 Wheel Bearing NTN ETCR10846LLCS1#01 Array Indirect Details»
DT Components 513058 Wheel Bearing DT Components 513058 Array Indirect Details»
Fenco WH510058 Wheel Brg Fenco WH510058 Array Indirect Details»
FORD E6DZ-1215A Wheel Bearing FORD E6DZ-1215A Array Indirect Details»
L&S Bearing FV3028 Wheel Bearing L&S Bearing FV3028 Array Indirect Details»
FORD E9DZ-1215A Wheel Bearing FORD E9DZ-1215A Array Indirect Details»
FEDERAL MOGUL 513058 Wheel Bearing FEDERAL MOGUL 513058 Array Indirect Details»
GREEN RW824 Wheel Bearing GREEN RW824 Array Indirect Details»
NSK 42BWD19 Wheel Brg NSK 42BWD19 Array Indirect Details»
NSK 42BWD19CA33** Wheel Brg NSK 42BWD19CA33** Array Indirect Details»
NSK 42BWD19CA33**,F Wheel Brg NSK 42BWD19CA33**,F Array Indirect Details»
OE 0K552-33-047 Wheel Bearing OE 0K552-33-047 Array Indirect Details»
OE 0K56A-33-047 Wheel Bearing OE 0K56A-33-047 Array Indirect Details»
OE
Last edited by Motorhead; 08-20-2014 at 01:38 PM.
Your problem isn't the problem. Your reaction is the problem.
So any verdict on the "CORRECT" wheel bearings for our trucks? I have a bad one on my new 03 setup, and have the two on my truck now to replace them, but I would rather press in new CORRECT wheel bearings that won't fail or have play after 2k miles. I have the equipment available to press in new ones and would rather do that than buy new hub assemblies.
Just bought these for my 03 setup: TIMKEN HA599528
- Josh
2000 Solar Yellow R/T - Cam Only Truck
1987 Buick Regal T-Type - WE4 and Blackout
2008 GMC 1500 Quad Cab
1989 Jeep YJ - Real Jeeps have Square Headlights
1971 Buick Skylark - LS SWAP THE WORLD
- Josh
2000 Solar Yellow R/T - Cam Only Truck
1987 Buick Regal T-Type - WE4 and Blackout
2008 GMC 1500 Quad Cab
1989 Jeep YJ - Real Jeeps have Square Headlights
1971 Buick Skylark - LS SWAP THE WORLD
I just ordered new Timkin hubs from Rock Auto on Sunday (a day before this topic )
From what I can tell they are Japanese bearings
Bearing ET-CRI-0846
Hub HA599528
Did I get crap or what?
I don't think mine necessarily NEED to be replaced. I have to do a full brake job on the front so I figured I'd replace the hubs while I had it apart.
I think I'm just gonna send these back and wait...
- Josh
2000 Solar Yellow R/T - Cam Only Truck
1987 Buick Regal T-Type - WE4 and Blackout
2008 GMC 1500 Quad Cab
1989 Jeep YJ - Real Jeeps have Square Headlights
1971 Buick Skylark - LS SWAP THE WORLD
I have used the Timken Set 49's two different times on my truck, once when the truck was just out of warranty and the second time just last year. Both times they worked like they should.
The attached link is the type of hub bearing used on the Dakotas, it is a dual tapered roller bearing in one housing. If someone has come across one that is ball bearings, it is not correct.
http://www.timken.com/en-us/products...es/Unipac.aspx
Last edited by 9t9-5.2; 08-20-2014 at 11:07 PM.
You guys need to just stop messing with this bearing replacement crap and buy brand new hubs from the dealer and know it's done right.
BLACK '02 RC R/T (BLACK N BITTER) 12.5 @ 109 mph. Under the knife again.
'99 IB RC R/T (Sabrina's truck) 13.8 @ 96 mph SOLD!
'10 B5 blue pearl Challenger R/T Classic edition. Totaled!!! FML!!!
'98 CC R/T Bought wrecked. Restoring it.
'05 WRANGLER (DD)
'05 HARLEY FXDCI
I've got 6 years on a Timken hub on my truck with no issues.
I have 5 lug hubs so I can't just replace the hub.
Timken Set 49 bearings are loose
11.27 @ 118.232017 NM Mopar Challenge Series Champion
Josh - 98 BLK RC - Mad Milkshake Maker
Previous
99 BLK RC - Mad Trash Hauler - sold
99 DA RC - mad dak - Danno Stole it
01 SLVR RC - mad sexy - retired - then died
99 IB RC - mad RT - gone to heaven..
Former Certified member of the 11 Second NA RT Club